Pipikaula Corner: Money or power

What do people mean when they say they're going to "dismantle capitalism?" It's a message that seemed to resonate in the 2026 elections, so you have to pay attention to the language to know what's really going on.

AKN
A. Kam Napier

November 18, 20266 min read

Furious hipster guy breaking with bat currency symbol. Mixed media
(iStock | Sergey Khakimullin)

In the wake of the 2026 midterms, Democrats are feeling ascendant, particularly the hard leftwing that’s taking over the mainstream Democratic party. You can hear their siren call 24/7 now, whether it's coming from James Talarico or the Indivisible Hawai‘i marchers who periodically descend upon the state Capitol, and it sounds like this:

Capitalism bad, capitalism bad, capitalism bad! We’re going to dismantle the system of capitalist oppression and liberate you!

They are running a con, a scam, a grift. Like all successful cons, it has a powerful appeal. You, personally, feel like things are too expensive while other people have so much, and they sound like they care and have the answer to all of life’s unfairness. Perhaps you’re not feeling especially secure or confident in yourself right now, so their pitch has your attention.

Brief reminder: “Con” is short for “confidence.” Con artists of all stripes cultivate an air of cocky assuredness, or comforting strong reassurance, so that people who don’t feel confident will latch on to them and give them control. That’s when they squeeze their victim for every penny they have.

One path to real confidence is knowledge, so I want to talk about something these DSA-type are talking about, but differently, so you can see the game they’re running on you.

Money.

When they talk about “capitalism” they are talking about the meaning of money. Other people’s money, your money. “Capitalism,” the way they say it, is a reductionist slur that Karl Marx and his fellow travelers use to sneer at an entire social system. That particular system is the way in which people use money — capital — as a tool for negotiating their time, energy and talents in exchange for the goods and services they need.

In a market system, humanity under “capitalism” has unlocked a level of freedom and prosperity over the past two centuries that are unheard of in the vast scope of history.

One of the amazing things about our market system is the degree to which what we do for a living is voluntary. Not everyone loves or even likes their job, but quite a lot of people do. We live in a society in which you can ask kids, “What do you want to be when you grow up?” and realistically expect that they have a meaningful choice. This has not been the norm in human history. If we like that — and I do! — we better think carefully about preserving the system that makes it possible. One thing that makes is possible is that money is a neutral medium by which all those free choices are exchanged.

Money is also a highly abstract, complex subject. I’ve come to understand it only through metaphors. Two of these metaphors have helped me understand money better — what it does for me, what it does in society.

One, you can think of it as being a form of social energy that functions like electricity. Money, like watts in a wire, makes things happen. What are we exchanging with this medium of exchange? Effort. Work. Time. Example: I don’t farm, you likely don’t farm, but we need to eat, so we do work that we can to get money — recharge our battery — then we give that money to farmers. Then the farmers have energy that they can send to the people they depend on. We power each other up. And in the same way that electricity can power up appliances as varied as refrigerators and razors and iPhones and toasters, money can power an editor or a farmer or small business owner. The money doesn’t care, it’ll power you up. Everyone can spend it, everyone can receive it and in that we are all equal, even if we have different amounts. A buck is a buck for everyone. It's energy for everyone.

Two, you can think of it as a language, one with mathematical precision. I can go to Banana Republic and say I like a dress shirt a lot, but so what? How much do I like it, really? Well, not $120 worth. Catch me at the sale rack where I’ll be saying very exactly that I like it $40 worth. If you've ever negotiated a salary or asked for a raise, you're expressing how much you value yourself and the work being done. If dollars are like words, the more money you have, the bigger your vocabulary, the more you can say.

Now imagine all this electricity and all this vocabulary flowing through society. It’s a vibrant hum of actions taken, deeds accomplished, values expressed. That’s capitalism at its best.

However, one thing you notice is that the energy and vocabulary are not spread evenly. Under “capitalism,” more humans than ever have generated and received more energy than ever in history, but unevenly.

This is where the con artists pry their way into your brain. Imagine … just imagine ... if we could take away the power that money has over your life! Imagine if we could take away the power that people with money have over your life! You will be free!

Give us political power and we will take care of everything. We will take from the rich and give to the poor!

Listen to that pitch closely. It’s a confession. Notice especially “power” and “take.”

Sure, we could scrap the whole idea of money as a neutral medium of exchange. We invented it in the distant past, chose to stick with it for thousands of years, we could choose to stop. Why not? Let’s think of all the misery that a lack of money has caused and ban the stuff immediately.

Then what happens? Make money — capital — disappear and what will remain?

About eight billion humans, hungry, in the dark, stripped of all economic energy and language. Somehow, we would still need to negotiate who does what, where they do it, when and how, so that we all may eat, live in dwellings that protect us from nature, wear clothing, obtain medicine and so on.

But how, without money? The DSA has told us their alternative: “Power” and “take.”

There is exactly one form of energy that can restart that engine, absent the electricity of money. The old way, the original way, the way of nature:

Force.

That’s what is hiding inside the anticapitalist promise of the DSA. That’s what “power” and “take” warn us. They would replace the power of capital — which, yes, is distributed unevenly — with the power of raw force, which they are flat-out bragging they will control exclusively.

We would trade lives determined by what we can afford for lives determined by our obedience.

There have been hints of what this will look like already in the modern West.

Force flex: February 2022, the Canadian government debanked truckers who protested its Covid policies. Just reached right into the internet through the banks and froze their accounts. Disappeared them, economically. That's what "smashing capitalism" really looks like, top down. Remember how I said a dollar is a dollar for everyone and so we are all equal? Canada decided some dollars were less equal than others and could not be spent by people committing wrongthink.

Force flex: Act 11, in which Hawai‘i's legislature used political power to ban businesses and nonprofits — the private sector as it commonly organizes itself into groups of shared interests — from spending money on elections, for or against candidates, for or against ballot initiatives. When they said they passed this bill to "get money out politics" think of what that means in terms of my metaphor. Stop seeing "money" and see instead a blackout and a gag. That's what they imposed. Not for everyone, of course. Just the private sector. Just us, the people they tax and regulate.

Look abroad and further back. There have been entire societies based on power and taking rather than capital and freedom. In the 20th century, these societies amassed a death toll of 130 million, according to the late R.J. Rummel, a University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa professor who coined the term democide to describe governments deliberately killing their own citizens, usually with the promise of making them equal. Does that sound extreme? Can't happen here? Why not? People who think they've been given a mandate for "power" and "taking" will not want to be interrupted.

"Dismantle capitalism!" It’s easy to fall for that pitch when you’re looking, right here and now, at what you can’t afford and haven’t looked 10, or 20 or 100 years down the road, when the con plays itself out to the fullest and the real price must be paid. Get beyond the pitch, and ask yourself, what comes next? And what comes after that?

There would still be money, of course, but it won’t facilitate free exchange, it will only be used to facilitate force. And on the other side of their glorious people’s revolution of equity, you will have no force. They will control the social electricity; they will be the only ones who can speak the language of money.

Everything will be free but you.

A. Kam Napier is editor in chief of Aloha State Daily. His opinions in Pipikaula Corner are his own and not reflective of the ASD team.

For the latest news of Hawai‘i, sign up here for our free Daily Edition newsletter.

Authors

AKN

A. Kam Napier

Editor-In-Chief

A. Kam Napier is Editor-in-Chief for Aloha State Daily.