Hawaiʻi's Japan problem isn't tourism. It's business.

Tourism from Japan remains half what it was before the Covid lockdowns and Hawai‘i has yet to figure out a way forward, writes ASD columnist Ray Tsuchiyama. What if we courted its capital and investment in the same way we built a sophisticated system for attracting its visitors?

RT
Ray Tsuchiyama

November 20, 20264 min read

panoramic, tourist attractions in the city park of Tokyo, Asia business concept image, panoramic modern cityscape building in Japan.
Tokyo. (iStock | pinglabel)

In 1899 – six years after the Kingdom overthrow and in the final year of the Republic of Hawaiʻi – my grandparents landed on Maui. My father was born in Puʻunēnē plantation camp and raised in Japan. My mother is from Japan’s northern frontier: Hokkaido. I was born in Japan, speak Japanese, and worked in Tokyo for two decades. Our family has been a bridge between Hawaiʻi and Japan for five generations. So, when Covid lockdowns emptied the flights from Narita and Haneda to Hawaiʻi, I watched the relationship I grew up inside of nearly disappear overnight.

It hasn't come back.

In 2019 — the golden year — over 1.5 million Japanese visitors came to Hawaiʻi. In recent years, that number has hovered around 800,000. Less than half.

Three years ago, I published an Op-Ed essay, "Attracting Japanese Visitors to Hawaiʻi: Version 2.0," laying out why: the weak yen, Hawaiʻi 's soaring prices, shifting travel habits, and a fraying of the Japanese-language hospitality that once set Hawaiʻi apart. My conclusion then was that we needed a new visitor strategy.

Today, I ask a different question: What did Hawaiʻi actually learn when its most important international market vanished? Did we use that shock to build something beyond tourism?

Not enough. And we are still measuring the entire Hawai‘i-Japan relationship by how many people step off a Boeing 787.

For decades, the dynamic ran one way: Japan → Hawai‘i → tourists → hotels, shopping, restaurants, golf, real estate. That was Version 1.0.

My earlier essay argued for Version 2.0 — supplementing tourism with targeted business investment.

Now, Hawaii needs Version 3.0: A genuinely broad economic relationship spanning tourism, investment, technology, trade, education, research, and high-paying jobs. Especially jobs — the kind that keep young local talent here instead of losing them to Seattle, the Bay Area, or Southern California.

Japanese visitors remain vital to Hawai‘i, and nothing here argues for abandoning them. But the pandemic exposed the structural weakness of leaning entirely on one market's Business-to-Consumer (B2C) spending.

There are other layers waiting to be built: Japanese companies investing directly in Hawai‘i; Hawai‘i firms exporting to Japan; and Hawai‘i serving as a U.S. base for Japanese companies expanding across the Pacific. That is a Business-to-Business (B2B) framework, not a B2C one — and it represents a far larger economic horizon than anything measured at Daniel K. Inouye International Airport.

Let’s be honest about what Hawai‘i cannot win. We are not going to out-bid Georgia, Texas, or Tennessee for a major manufacturing plant — U.S., Japanese, German, or otherwise. Those states offer cheap land, massive industrial footprints, low electricity costs, deep labor pools, and research universities churning out engineers by the thousands. Hawai‘i cannot compete on those terms, and it shouldn't try.

What Hawai‘i has instead: geographic and cultural proximity to Japan inside the security of the U.S. legal and financial system; a world-class tourism infrastructure; Pacific-wide diplomatic and cultural connections; specialized marine and environmental research institutions; and a population with deep, generational ties to Japan. The task is converting those assets into economic opportunity rather than living off nostalgia of a “golden” Hawai‘i-Japan past.

Hawai‘i doesn't need every Japanese enterprise to build a factory here. It needs to ask: "What can Japanese companies and Hawai‘i accomplish together that neither could do as easily alone?"

Consider Hawai‘i as a real-world testbed: hospitality innovation, renewable micro-grids, senior care services, ocean technology, aquaculture, and ag-tech. Imagine Hawai‘i universities co-developing IP with Japanese firms, matching Japanese capital and scale with Hawai‘i research and entrepreneurial talent. Currently, almost no one in state leadership is systematically driving this — yet it could diversify our economy within a generation.

Every version of this question eventually brings me back to growing up in Kalihi-Pālama — and what might actually move the needle for a kid attending Fern Elementary, Kalākaua Middle, or Farrington High today. Note: Japanese remains the top foreign language at state public schools – an impressive ranking I will discuss in later columns.

Success should not be measured by how many Japanese corporate logos open a branch office in Waikīkī. It should be measured by capital invested, high-paying jobs created, technology transferred, market access opened for Hawai‘i businesses in Tokyo, and lasting research partnerships built. That is the fundamental difference between tourism promotion and true economic development.

Hawai‘i built sophisticated machinery — HTA, HVCB, Meet Hawai‘i, HLTA — to attract Japanese tourists. Where is the equivalent statewide machinery tasked with attracting Japanese capital, technology, and corporate partnerships?

Tourism should be one pillar of the Hawai‘i-Japan relationship, not the entire building. My grandparents saw Hawai‘i as America's bridge to Japan. The coming decade is our chance to rebuild that bridge — not just for more visitors, but for investment, innovation, trade, and better livelihoods for the people who call Hawai‘i home.

The question isn't whether Hawai‘i needs a Japan strategy. It's what that strategy should look like — and whether we are organized to execute it.

In upcoming columns, I will explore how Hawai‘i should adopt a different Japan strategy and how other states attract Japanese investment – in surprising ways.

Ray Tsuchiyama’s series explores one central question: How does Hawai‘i use the wealth and land it already has to create its next economic future? He can be reached at ray@guild.im 

For the latest news of Hawai‘i, sign up here for our free Daily Edition newsletter.

Authors

RT

Ray Tsuchiyama

Ray Tsuchiyama is a Guild Consulting partner. He specializes in real estate portfolio strategy, family wealth, and long-term property stewardship. His career has spanned M.I.T., Castle & Cooke, Google, and Cushman & Wakefield ChaneyBrooks. Raised in Kalihi-Pālama and a two-decade Japan resident, he is fluent in Japanese and has studied Hawaiian language, bringing a Hawaiʻi, Mainland and international perspective to real estate and economic development. A former Maui County commissioner and Board member of the Pacific and Asian Affairs Council, he has written for The New York Times, Forbes, Japan Times, and The Hawaiian Journal of History. His Maui News blog received several Society of Professional Journalists awards. He and his Guild colleagues are occasional columnists for Aloha State Daily; the views expressed are their own.