The room had no windows. It was an ordinary prison room at the Women’s Community Correctional Center in Kailua, and Kēhau Manijo went to the church service there because, in her words, it was something to do. The pastor asked if anyone wanted to be saved. She heard herself say yes.
That scene sits near the end of a nearly 6,000-word piece by Civil Beat’s John Hill, who traces the stories of four Hawaiians through decades of meth use. The vignettes include prison, children taken by the state, trucks repossessed, a tent on the North Shore, and two bodies lying still in a stairwell on School Street.
Two of the four died. Two lived. Hill’s series will shape how the state spends on meth for years to come, and this installment contains the plainest evidence of what works. But the reporter skirts around the evidence.
Hill weaves a good story, and he’s willing to show Christian faith that many reporters would minimize.
He brings the reader into Manijo’s prison conversion. He prints Kapu Shoaf’s desperate late-night prayer, “God, if you’re really there, just hear me, I don’t like die this way, but I don’t see no way out. But if you heal me one more time, I’m not gonna hit that pipe no more … Heal me one more time, like you did before when I was 15.”
He also follows their stories: Kēhau Manijo sobered up, was released from prison, and divorced her husband Tommy. She now runs a sober home in Waiʻanae. Kapu Shoaf prayed and got sober.
A hostile writer would have cut the stories of salvation, or filed them under jailhouse religion. Hill did neither. The honest man reports faithfully what he himself cannot profess.
The problem with his story is that the anecdotes pile up, and after nearly 6,000 words, Hill leaves the reader to sort out what matters.
What explains meth addiction and recovery, in Hill’s story? He cites a University of Hawaiʻi study which found that Native Hawaiians were almost twice as likely as the state population to use meth. He points to childhood trauma. And he gestures toward publicly funded rehab programs which don’t work.
But two of his four subjects suggest that the thing that finally worked was God. A third wears a cross. The fourth repents just in time.
Hill writes in the neutral style the Associated Press prescribes for every newsroom in the country. He can write in his own voice that “Meth use is the backdrop of many child welfare cases.” But he cannot write in his own voice that conversion is the backdrop of recovery, though his four lives support the second sentence more than the first.
There is nothing wrong with citing studies. Statistics tell us things that stories can’t, and a reporter who ignored them would be worse at his job. The trouble is upstream of the numbers. It lies in the editor’s decision about which facts are allowed to carry weight.
That decision was made before Hill’s notebook opened, and his reporting is built on the wrong account of man I wrote about in August: corruption comes from outside, so the cure must come from outside too. Fix the surroundings and the man will follow.
Kēhau Manijo quit the first time, in the 1990s, when her father sat her down with tears in his eyes and said there would be no more money on her books and no home to come home to. She threw the ice away that night. But she returned to drugs. She quit the second time in a windowless prison room, as she received salvation.
Kapu Shoaf got clean praying in bed the night she saw no way out. She stays clean by keeping a small circle of sober friends.
Tommy Manijo stopped for a while after a diagnosis of congestive heart failure, then found that when the drug crowd stopped coming by, he “had to actually deal with himself.” He couldn’t. The last thing his ex-wife told him was to get right with God. He agreed, and died of meth that night.
Lily Shoaf went through nearly every rehab program on Oʻahu. Two of them worked, for years at a time. But relapse followed. Lily was accepted into another rehab on a December afternoon in 2024 and died of overdose a few hours later. A golden cross hangs from Lily’s neck in two photos, but Hill does not ask or answer any questions about Lily’s faith.
In Hill’s telling, addiction is something that happens to a person, like childhood trauma. His reporting makes a little room for faith. But not enough room for faith to have done anything.
In the photographs, an angel-shaped ornament hangs from a mirror in Kēhau Manijo’s sober home.
And a gold cross hangs at Lily Shoaf’s neck. Hill never asked about it. He should have.
Author Sterling Higa can be reached at hello@sterlinghiga.com.
For the latest news of Hawai‘i, sign up here for our free Daily Edition newsletter.
