Kamehameha Schools defends admissions policy in court

Lawsuit alleging discrimination in Kamehameha Schools' admission policy may be dismissed pending a ruling on a Tuesday hearing.

MB
Michael Brestovansky

November 18, 20263 min read

Kamehameha Schools trustee Crystal Rose speaks Tuesday.
Kamehameha Schools trustee Crystal Rose speaks Tuesday. (Courtesy | Kamehameha Schools)

Supporters of Kamehameha Schools crowded into a U.S. District courtroom Tuesday as a lawsuit challenging the schools’ admissions policy proceeds.

In Oct. 2025, the Virginia-based nonprofit Students for Fair Admissions filed suit against Kamehameha Schools, calling its admissions policy illegal race-based discrimination. More than one year later, the case could be dismissed, pending a ruling by U.S. District Court Judge Micah Smith.

Smith heard arguments by both KS and SFFA for and against dismissing case, respectively, on Tuesday, with dozens of KS supporters in attendance.

Tuesday’s hearing arose from an amended complaint SFFA filed in July, the fifth such complaint filed since the case started. The complaint still lists the original plaintiffs — two anonymous families who have said they would prefer their daughters to attend KS — but also includes co-plaintiffs added since the suit was initially filed: two high school students who were rejected by KS when they applied in previous years, and those students’ mothers.

John Bash, attorney for KS, argued to Smith that the new complaint has failed to prove that KS’ admissions policy — which provides preference to Native Hawaiian students — violates the Civil Rights Act of 1991.

In large part, Bash’s arguments revolved around extensive legal precedent allowing Congress to exempt a private school from federal civil liability. He said that, for the nearly 150 years since the establishment of KS, Congress has explicitly recognized a special relationship between the U.S. and Native Hawaiians, and by so doing has supported KS’ mission of preserving Hawaiian culture for Hawaiian students.

That special relationship was upheld during a series of previous lawsuits challenging KS’ admissions policy between 2003 and 2007, Bash said. Those suits led to Congress enacting a law expressly allowing KS to continue its admissions policy unimpeded by the Civil Rights Act.

However, even were that not the case, Bash argued that SFFA’s complaint has failed to prove that the complainants have been actually injured by KS’ admissions policy. The two unnamed families never actually submitted an application that KS could have rejected, and Bash argued that the complaint doesn’t prove that the prospective students would have been accepted even if their ancestry wasn’t in question.

SFFA attorney Cameron Norris countered that people are not required to submit a futile application in order to claim injury by a discriminatory policy, and argued that, if the case is allowed to proceed to discovery, the court could shed light on the inner workings of KS’ admissions policy: whether the plaintiffs would have met the school’s academic requirements, among other things.

Meanwhile, Bash said, the matter is moot because, as of February, KS no longer charges tuition. This, he argued, exempts KS from another of SFFA’s arguments, that KS’ paid admissions constitute discriminatory contracts; by moving from a tuition model to a “cost-free gift,” Bash said it no longer involves contractual relationships with students or their families at all.

But Norris was unconvinced, arguing that KS’ student policies, privacy waivers and even on-campus vending machines all qualify as actual or de facto contracts between the school and its students. Therefore, Norris said, KS is still engaged in contracting and cannot elide accusations of discriminatory contracts by claiming it has no contracts.

The arguments went with no conclusion Tuesday. Smith gave no ruling nor any indication of when a ruling might be forthcoming.

KS’ only issued a brief statement in connection with the hearing, reiterating that the School “remains committed to its educational mission and will continue to vigorously defend that mission.”

But KS supporters and trustees spoke before the hearing in support of the school and its admissions policy. Trustee Crystal Rose, who was an attorney for KS in the previous suits in the early 2000s, said KS carries the legacy of nearly 150 years of students.

“We enter this courtroom prepared: with the law on our side, with our history as our foundation and with an unwavering understanding of who we serve,” Rose said. “We will pursue every legal avenue available to us to defend Pauahi’s estate, her intent and our ability to fulfill her wishes.”

For the latest news of Hawai‘i, sign up here for our free Daily Edition newsletter.

Authors

MB

Michael Brestovansky

Government & Politics Reporter

Michael Brestovansky is a Government and Politics reporter for Aloha State Daily covering crime, courts, government and politics.