Fishponds, a Prison, and Brothels in Old Iwilei

Iwilei has undergone tremendous change over the years. Once a region of fishponds and wetlands, it became home to rail yards and industries, a prison known as The Reef and a notorious red-light district. If the workers in the former Kmart in Iwilei are right, the area is still home some troubled spirits as well.

LKaTK
Lopaka Kapanui and Tanya Kapanui

November 18, 20264 min read

Old Kmart Building Iwilei Large
The former Kmart in Iwilei (Mysteries of Hawai‘i)

Driving along Nimitz Highway through the industrial center of Iwilei, it’s hard to imagine what it looked like before the warehouses and buildings. Before the space was filled with dredge from the harbor, the ocean came nearly up to where Nimitz Highway runs now. Most of the area consisted of wetlands and fishponds fed by streams that came down from Nu‘uanu Valley.

Two of the largest fishponds were Kawa and Kūwili, which provided food for generations of Hawaiians. Kalo was cultivated in the surrounding lowlands, and rice fields eventually became part of the landscape as well.

In 1857, O‘ahu Prison was built on a small strip of land between the two fishponds. It was often referred to as Kawa Prison due to its location, or The Reef because of its coral-rock construction. Along with the structure came Prison Road, the beginning of access to what was once a relatively isolated area just outside Honolulu.

When the O‘ahu Railway and Land Company established its Honolulu depot in Iwilei in 1889, it created a major turning point for the area. The railroad needed room for its tracks, freight yards, and shipping facilities, while at the same time, extensive harbor improvements also needed somewhere to offload tons of displaced sand and coral. The surrounding wetlands and fishponds were filled in to accommodate development. By 1901, hundreds of acres of new waterfront land had been created, significantly expanding the Iwilei area.

The region also acquired a very different reputation around the turn of the century. Although prostitution had existed in Honolulu for decades, the bubonic plague crisis and the subsequent destruction of Chinatown in the January 1900 fire eventually led to an established red-light district in Iwilei. The district, commonly associated with the Iwilei Stockade, was considered “a public necessity,” and was a government-tolerated and police-regulated area where prostitution was generally confined to a designated part of the neighborhood. Its presence brought a different population into the broader Iwilei area, including laborers, sailors, and other transient workers who visited the district. Although police supervision generally kept large public disturbances within the district to a minimum, violence and exploitation were part of the territory.

Over time, the fishponds disappeared beneath streets, railroad tracks, warehouses, and industrial buildings, and Iwilei lost nearly all of its agricultural character. The shoreline was reshaped to accommodate the demands of a growing commercial port. By the 1920s, the neighborhood was increasingly defined by its industrial and commercial enterprises.

Today, it is difficult to imagine that this busy industrial district was once a landscape of fishponds and wetlands. Its history also includes a prison, a notorious red-light district, and industries that helped shape modern Honolulu. Yet beneath the pavement and buildings, the history of old Iwilei remains tied to the land.

Hawaii’s first Kmart store opened in Iwilei in 1992 to long lines, traffic backed up in all directions, and record first-day sales. Many of us still remember the seemingly endless congestion on Nimitz Highway and the surrounding area of the newly opened Kmart store. Lines to get into the store wrapped around the block, while workers ran frantically through the aisles, trying to restock the shelves as quickly as possible. According to newspapers, there were still more than 500 people in the store at its 9 p.m closing time.

Although the Iwilei Kmart store closed in 2016, former employees and vendors still share their haunted stories. One man said he worked as a vendor at the Kmart store and often had to get merchandise from the warehouse across the street. As a vendor, a manager was required to escort him to the warehouse, but they often refused to enter the space and waited for him at the door. They spoke of merchandise falling off the tops of the shelves and boxes falling over for no reason.

Another man shared his experience as a former associate who worked at the store shortly before it closed. He said there was always loud banging on the roll-up door. Everyone in the store could hear it. It was unsettling when he first heard it, and he noticed none of his coworkers seemed bothered. They told him it was annoying, but they were used to it. He said he was told that it had been happening for years. Management tried to look into it but couldn’t find a reason for the noise. Mechanically, nothing was wrong. Cameras showed no one in the area who could be pounding on the door, and security stationed within view never saw anyone coming or going when the noise started or stopped.

At first, he said he thought the talk about boxes and other items falling down in the warehouse was just baseless rumors and practical jokes. That is until he watched a box fall right in front of him while he was searching the shelves for an item. He was adamant that no one else was in the warehouse. On the sales floor, similar things happened.

Although Hawai‘i’s first Kmart store opened to record sales, the years leading up to its closing saw aisles nearly empty of customers. That’s what gave the man chicken skin when something weird happened. Clothes would fly off the racks without anyone near them, and he said he often felt like someone was behind him, tapping him on the shoulder. He’d turn to find no one. While these incidents seem minor, they can be deeply unsettling and make one question their own sanity.

Are these disturbances tied to the violence of the red light district? Or could they be related to something much older? Since the store closed, the building was reconfigured to accommodate new retailers. We haven’t heard anything from the people working in those stores … yet.

 The authors can be reached at hawaii.mysteries@gmail.com

For the latest news of Hawai‘i, sign up here for our free Daily Edition newsletter.

Authors

LKaTK

Lopaka Kapanui and Tanya Kapanui

For more than 25 years, I’ve been sharing Hawai‘i’s haunted history, weaving together folklore, history, and firsthand accounts to bring our ghost stories to life. As a Native Hawaiian born and raised on O‘ahu, I grew up listening to traditional mo‘olelo from my kūpuna, stories that shaped my passion for preserving our Islands’ supernatural and cultural heritage. That passion has led me to a lifetime of storytelling, earning a special citation from the Hawai‘i State Legislature for my work in keeping these legends alive. My wife, Tanya, and I run Mysteries of Hawai‘i, a locally owned ghost tour company dedicated to exploring the eerie and unexplained. Tanya, a lifelong horror enthusiast and researcher of hauntings and native legends, and I have co-authored "Hawaiʻi’s Night Marchers: A History of the Huaka‘i Po" and "Kahuna," our first full-length novel.  As weekly columnists, we are thrilled to share our love for Hawaiʻi’s history, haunted and otherwise, with Aloha State Daily readers. Hawai‘i has some of the most chilling and fascinating supernatural tales in the world, and we can’t wait to bring them to you.