'Clean Slate' proposal would hide certain criminal records from background checks

Advocates propose 2027 bill that would shield certain criminal records from showing up in criminal background checks after a certain period of time has passed.

MB
Michael Brestovansky

November 19, 20263 min read

Michelle Manalo
Michelle Manalo (Courtesy | Clean Slate Hawai‘i)

Hawai‘i advocates are hoping the state Legislature will pass a bill next year that will shield certain arrest and conviction records from showing up in background checks.

Clean Slate Hawai‘i, a coalition of Hawai‘i partners and advocates, are calling for Hawai‘i to become the 15th state to enact a “Clean Slate” law next year, which will prevent standard online background checks from pulling up certain criminal records after a certain period of time has passed.

Carrie Ann Shirota of Clean Slate Hawai‘i told Aloha State Daily that people with convictions on their record, or even with mere arrest records that never led to a criminal conviction, face significant barriers in gaining employment or housing.

Shirota said these “collateral consequences” of a criminal record constitute a long-term punishment that extends years beyond the actual end of a person’s legally mandated criminal sentence, even if the person has not reoffended since then. She said the stigma disincentivizes rehabilitation for people with convictions, and makes it more likely for people to reoffend.

In Hawai‘i, about 315,000 adults have arrest or conviction records that show up on a standard background check. The Clean State Initiative — a national nonprofit founded by the Center for American Progress that advocates for criminal expungement laws throughout the country — estimates that the reduced employment rates and earnings for people with these records equates to about $440 billion in lost annual earnings nationwide, or about $2.2 billion in Hawai‘i.  

Shirota said that, as other states adopt Clean Slate measures, more out-of-state employees who seek work here will have their records shielded, while local workers will not.

“It’s more of a workforce development measure than criminal justice reform,” Shirota said.

Michelle Manalo of Clean Slate Hawai‘i said she has faced obstacles to career advancement after multiple drug-related convictions more than a decade ago. She told ASD that people with criminal backgrounds may find themselves unable to rise beyond entry-level positions, and that landlords may reject potential tenants.

“The stigma’s still there,” Manalo said. “It’s tough to see people’s goals slip away, how they lose their confidence … They can be the hardest workers, they want to prove they’re in a better place. People do change.”

Technically, Shirota said, Hawai‘i has laws restricting how deep employers can look into a candidate’s criminal background. State statutes permit employers to inquire into a candidate’s conviction record only for the past five years for misdemeanor convictions, or the past seven years for felony convictions, and for the most part only after the employer has made a conditional job offer to the candidate.

In practice, however, Shirota said these laws are imperfect and can be skirted via third-party criminal history screening services.

The state also has a criminal expungement process, which allows for certain non-conviction arrest records to be purged from the Hawai‘i Criminal Justice Data Center. But Shirota said this process is cumbersome and requires a person to be aware of the process and initiate it themselves.

By contrast, a clean slate law would automatically prevent certain records from being searchable in the Hawai‘i Criminal Justice Data Center at all, which Shirota said merely helps effectuate a law already on the books.

The specifics of the proposed bill are still being worked out — a task force formed in 2024 to investigate the potential of the measure is scheduled to deliver recommendations for the measure on Dec. 10, Shirota said. Nonetheless, other states have implemented a “waiting period” for various offenses, and if a person has received no criminal conviction once that waiting period is over, the record of that conviction becomes shielded.

Shirota said the length of the waiting period is typically commensurate with the severity of the offense, with more serious crimes meriting longer waiting periods.

Clean Slate Hawai‘i will be “pushing for the broadest eligibility possible,” Shirota said, which would only exclude from shielding convictions for offenses that lead to a person being placed on a sex offender registry. However, she added that in the inevitable course of the legislative process, lawmakers will likely make compromises for stricter rules.

All criminal records affected by the measure would still be fully available to law enforcement.

For the latest news of Hawai‘i, sign up here for our free Daily Edition newsletter.

Authors

MB

Michael Brestovansky

Government & Politics Reporter

Michael Brestovansky is a Government and Politics reporter for Aloha State Daily covering crime, courts, government and politics.