Four tankers arrived in Honolulu under Jones Act waiver

Since March, at least four fuel shipments arrived in Hawai‘i on foreign-flagged vessels under an ongoing exemption to the Jones Act.

MB
Michael Brestovansky

November 21, 20264 min read

A view of Honolulu Harbor from Aloha Tower.
A view of Honolulu Harbor from Aloha Tower. (Aloha State Daily Staff)

In the eight months since President Donald Trump partially suspended the Jones Act, at least four foreign-flagged vessels have delivered shipments to Hawai‘i.

In March, as the war in Iran caused oil prices to rise worldwide, Trump enacted a waiver on the Jones Act, the law that requires that all shipments between U.S. ports be carried out by U.S.-constructed and U.S.-crewed ships.

Since then, Trump has re-extended the waiver multiple times, most recently on Nov. 16; the waiver is currently set to continue until Valentine’s Day.

The waiver currently exempts 237 different goods such as petroleum products, fertilizers, natural gas products and biodiesels.

According to data from the U.S. Department of Transportation Maritime Administration, the only waivered vessel that was recorded to arrive at Honolulu Harbor was the MV High Leader, a Liberian-flagged tanker operated by petroleum company Sunoco, which arrived in Honolulu on May 27, carrying a shipment of more than 213,000 barrels of motor fuel and 74,000 barrels of diesel oil.

However, Jonathan Helton, senior policy analyst for the Grassroot Institute of Hawai‘i, said at least four vessels have arrived in the state under the waiver, carrying motor oil, propane and other fuel products. Bloomberg have reported that multiple shipments have been carried out under the waiver without being disclosed in MARAD’s official records.

Colin Grabow, associate director for libertarian think tank the Cato Institute, told ASD that the three other vessels to arrive in Hawai‘i were tankers that traveled to Hawai‘i through the Panama Canal from Louisiana and Texas in May and June.

Helton said the propane-carrying vessel — which Grabow identified as the Liberian-flagged Eiger Explorer — was particularly interesting: at present, no ship in the nation’s Jones Act-compliant fleet is equipped to transport propane. Most of the state’s propane shipments, consequently, come from Canada, as international shipments are not bound by the Jones Act.

The propane tanker that arrived in Honolulu, therefore, delivered the equivalent of about 17% of the state’s annual propane imports, Helton said.

Helton added that three of the four known vessels traveled via the Gulf Coast, something he said “basically never happens.”

“It’s been something like 20 years since Hawai‘i imported anything that came through the Gulf Coast,” Helton said.

The precise economic impact of the waiver on the state has not yet been determined, Helton said, although he added that Grassroot Institute is developing a report on the subject that should be completed in the near future.

“Each voyage can reasonably be inferred to represent a cost savings,” Grabow told ASD. “Had better/cheaper/more efficient options been available, the waiver voyages would not have taken place. How significant the savings are, however, is more difficult to say.”

However, Helton said, the extension of the waiver is not likely to bring a sea change to Hawai‘i’s shipping economy anytime soon.

While Helton said the added fuel shipments allowed by the waiver may have allowed Hawai‘i fuel providers or the Kapolei Par Refinery some operational flexibility, transportation companies are not likely to negotiate new contracts with foreign vessels that would be nullified once the waiver is rescinded.

“At some point, the war will end,” Helton said. “What that looks like afterward, we don’t know.”

Furthermore, the terms of the waiver have tightened since March. When it was first enacted, vessels empowered by the waiver were only required to notify U.S. Customs and Border Patrol when the voyage was underway or completed. But as of the August extension, waivered voyages can only happen if the U.S. Maritime Administration cannot identify a vessel within the Jones Act-approved fleet that can complete the shipment instead — all four vessels to Honolulu arrived before August.

Helton said this requirement has exposed some of the limitations of the Jones Act fleet: much of the fleet is aging, and many of the vessels that can technically complete a specific voyage may have reduced capacity or speed compared to foreign ships.

On the other hand, Helton suggested that the national impacts of the waiver could provide “a hint of what more permanent Jones Act reform could look like.”

“Interest groups are seeing they have options,” Helton said. “But without anything introduced in the Legislature, I don’t know if we’ll see this huge uptick in shipments.”

Hawai‘i Rep. Ed Case, who has called for Jones Act reform for years, supported the extension of the waiver this week, saying the need for the waiver is especially acute in an island state that’s reliant on external fossil fuel shipments.

But Helton noted that the results of the midterm elections mean other Democrat lawmakers — some of whom may represent districts with shipbuilding industries that benefit from the Jones Act — could provide pressure against potential Jones Act reform or further waiver extensions.

For the latest news of Hawai‘i, sign up here for our free Daily Edition newsletter.

Authors

MB

Michael Brestovansky

Government & Politics Reporter

Michael Brestovansky is a Government and Politics reporter for Aloha State Daily covering crime, courts, government and politics.